Judge James Ho on today’s cultural elites, truth-seeking, and the courage to stand alone.
James C. Ho is a Circuit Judge on the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit. Before taking the bench on January 4, 2018, he was co-chair of the national Appellate and Constitutional Law practice group and partner in the Dallas office of Gibson, Dunn & Crutcher.
This address was delivered at UATX on September 15, 2026. Introductions by UATX President Carlos Carvalho and The Federalist Society President and CEO Sheldon Gilbert.
00:00 — UATX student Max Weinstein performs the national anthem
01:52 — Welcome: Constitution Day and UATX's third academic year
04:02 — An $11 million gift to launch UATX's law program
06:39 — Sheldon Gilbert: "A republic, if you can keep it"
10:07 — Introducing Judge James Ho
12:33 — Judge Ho: three decades in FedSoc
14:53 — Why Judge Ho supports UATX
16:58 — Will Americans prove the Anti-Federalists right?
19:12 — “We don't disagree, we destroy"
20:14 — Elena Kagan's advice: "Don't do it"
22:02 — The cost of standing alone
23:56 — Clarence Thomas and the solo dissent
25:42 — Originalism
27:15 — If we're all originalists, why the controversy?
29:10 — Working the refs: judges, umpires, and the booing crowd
30:45 — Unanimity, and the lure of the inner ring
32:38 — Why Judge Ho stopped hiring clerks from top law schools
35:32 — “Duty is ours, results are God's"
37:52 — Q&A: Where do originalists disagree with each other?
40:16 — Q&A: What if only a few people stand up?
43:09 — Q&A: Advice for a conservative at a liberal university
46:36 — Q&A: How do you find north without a compass?
50:43 — Q&A: Is unanimity on the Court worth pursuing?
52:31 — Q&A: Judges striking down executive orders
54:18 — Q&A: Weren't the Anti-Federalists right?
56:47 — Q&A: What's the alternative to originalism?
Judge Ho's prepared remarks:
Thanks so much for that kind introduction. I’m profoundly honored to deliver your Constitution Day address this year.[….]
I’ve been a member of the Federalist Society for three decades. I started law school the fall of 1996.
I realize that, for many of you in this room, 1996 might as well be 1896. 1996 was certainly long before it was cool to be a member of the Federalist Society.
Now, some of you might say that it’s not cool today, either. And who knows—I might even agree with you.
But cool or not, I couldn’t hide my affiliation with the Federalist Society if I tried.
During the first Trump Administration, Senator Durbin routinely asked federal judicial nominees to state, in writing, how many of the Society’s annual conferences we’ve ever attended.
My answer was simple: All of them. Every one since law school.
Now, I think I was supposed to be embarrassed to say that. But I was happy to say it.
And I’m happy to be here today for the same reason: Because I’m excited about our country—about our Constitution—and about the University of Austin.
* * *
So much of what inspires me about our Constitution is also what inspires me about this campus.
And by the same token, so much of what concerns me about how cultural elites treat our Constitution mirrors my concerns about how they treat higher education.
Whether it’s the Constitution or higher education, we should all be dedicated to one thing—the pursuit of truth.
And that means we must be dedicated to maintaining the necessary preconditions for pursuing truth.
It means that we need intellectual honesty, rigor, and the freedom to speak, if we’re going to be able to pursue the truth, at all times, and at all costs, no matter where it leads us—and regardless of whether the answer is politically correct, or politically controversial.
That’s why Allyson and I are pleased to be strong supporters, and founding donors, to the University of Austin. Because we share your concerns about the direction of higher education in America. And we view the University of Austin as one of the Nation’s most promising signs of restoration—as well as an important signal to the incumbent institutions of higher ed.
Every university in America likes to boast that they’re training our next generation of leaders.
But too many institutions of higher education have become incubators of intolerance. Too many universities across America are failing in their basic mission to teach students how to become good citizens—let alone good leaders.
* * *
In a nation of over 300 million Americans, we’re bound to disagree on a wide number of issues. We’re committed to the same fundamental principles of liberty and equality. But we disagree fervently about what those principles require in practice. We weigh competing considerations differently. And these divergent value judgments inevitably lead to conflict.
Our nation’s Founders anticipated these concerns. The Federalists promised that the former colonies would be better off together—that we would enjoy numerous economic, diplomatic, security, and other advantages that flow from scale.
In response, the Anti-Federalists worried that no republic anywhere near our size and heterogeneity had ever been formed. They feared we were too diverse, and would bicker endlessly. They believed we would be better off apart.
The Federalists prevailed by offering two critical ingredients for avoiding endless conflict: federalism and freedom of speech.
We would do at the national level what must be done at the national level. But we would leave ample space for differing viewpoints. And we would have the freedom to advocate our beliefs and advance them in state and local communities nationwide.
Thank goodness the Federalists won. America is the most successful nation in human history.
But if we do not reverse the toxic environment on our nation’s campuses soon, I fear that we may ultimately prove the Anti-Federalists right.
Because our country won’t work, unless citizens can agree on the basic terms of our democracy.
We Americans are a diverse and passionate bunch. But we come together as one great nation. We work with each other, trade with one another, and treat our neighbors with respect and decency. And we engage others with a presumption of good faith, and in the earnest belief that there’s always something we can learn from our fellow man.
We expect parents to raise their children with these values. But we also look to our Nation’s schools to inculcate these principles in the next generation of Americans.
Unfortunately, too many educational institutions have stopped teaching students an essential skill of citizenship: knowing how to agree to disagree with one another.
What we’re seeing instead is antithetical both to the academy and to America. We don’t disagree—we destroy. We don’t talk—we tweet. We live in a culture of cancellation, not conversation. We don’t engage with one another—we expel people from social and economic life. It’s unsustainable—and, we fear, existential.
What’s worse, what happens on campus doesn’t stay on campus. Students learn the wrong lessons and practice the wrong tactics. And then they graduate and bring these tactics to workplaces across the country.
That’s why we’re so grateful for the founding of this University. Because this University is committed to education—not indoctrination. To teaching you how to think—not what to think. To lead boldly—not to follow blindly. To be humble—not haughty. And to always pursue the truth.
The success of the University of Austin is crucial, because so many other universities have failed.
My friend, law professor Brian Fitzpatrick, recently published some advice he got as a Harvard law student, from his then-Dean, now Justice, Elena Kagan.
He asked her about becoming a law professor. She asked him what field he wanted to pursue. He said: race discrimination law.
Kagan’s response: Don’t do it. Because she knew that Brian has conservative constitutionalist views on racial preferences. She explained that, at every law school in America, the scholars who worked in that area all supported racial preferences. She said that, for that reason alone, no one would ever support hiring him.
Brian took her advice. He pursued a different scholarly field—class action law. And he was able to gain entry into the academy as a result.
He learned what all of us who hold traditional views learn—that it’s always easier to avoid the substance, and just focus on procedure. Judges love to avoid the substance of a controversial dispute by finding some technical procedural escape route. We see it all the time in the courts.
I’m sure that Brian was grateful for Kagan’s candor. But I’m sure he found it jarring as well.
It reflects precisely the kind of ideological hegemony in higher education that the University of Austin was founded to combat.
So I welcome the University of Austin. I see it as a disruptive force. And I thank God for that.
* * *
Moreover, I see an important connection between what you’re doing here at the University of Austin, and what I see in the federal judiciary every day.
Just as there is pressure on university campuses to parrot the dominant orthodoxies of the day, there’s the same pressure to stay with the group—and not to stand alone—when it comes to writing judicial opinions as well.
So it turns out that disruption isn’t just what’s needed to restore higher education. Disruption is also what’s needed to restore our Constitution as well.
What you’re learning every day at the University of Austin is also what we need to protect and defend our Constitution. And that’s the paramount importance of being ready and willing to stand for what is right—regardless of what is popular—even if it means standing alone.
It’s not hard to find dramatic examples of what it costs to stand alone in our legal system.
A lone juror in Massachusetts recently cast a lonely vote against a criminal defendant who has become a folk hero in certain cultural elite circles. In response, his fellow jurors rushed to the television cameras to condemn him. Why? To quote one juror, because he would not “get[] off the fact that Lindsay viciously killed her children.” That lone juror is now facing nationwide media scrutiny into his personal life, for standing alone against the cultural zeitgeist. His family has now reportedly been forced to go into hiding.
The problem isn’t limited to one jury in Massachusetts. There are also costs to standing alone on the highest court of the land. Just ask Justice Clarence Thomas.
Senator Ted Cruz recently published a book that highlights Justice Thomas’s decades-long record of “going further” than any other Justice on the Court. If you read it, you’ll quickly discover that what Senator Cruz means is Justice Thomas’s record of going further by standing alone.
No one should be surprised to learn that Justice Thomas has penned more solo dissenting opinions than the rest of the current members of the Court combined.
But what matters most is not quantity, but quality. Justice John Paul Stevens actually wrote far more solo dissents than Justice Thomas—even though Thomas recently surpassed him in length of service on the Court. But Justice Stevens’s views noticeably drifted over time—garnering the adoration of those who control the national discourse—while Justice Thomas has held fast to his jurisprudential principles, and continued to express views detested by those cultural elites.
As a result, he’s been subject to unrelenting condemnation by the academy and in the media. Indeed, after just one year on the Court, the New York Times editorial board singled him out as the “youngest, cruelest justice,” for having the temerity to stand apart from his colleagues.
* * *
We’re here today to celebrate Constitution Day. So it seems appropriate to ponder what exactly it means to be faithful to the Constitution.
I would hope that it means that we respect the text of the Constitution—the words that our Founders wrote and ratified, as they understood them to mean.
In a word, being faithful to the Constitution simply means being an originalist.
But here’s the funny thing. One of the things that you’re told during the Senate confirmation process for federal judges is that, if you say that you’re an originalist, you should expect controversy.
But it shouldn’t be controversial at all. Every judge swears an oath to uphold the Constitution. So being an originalist is really just the job description. Because being an originalist just means being faithful to whatever text you’re interpreting.
Justice Thomas has repeatedly described himself as an “originalist.”
So have Justices Ginsburg, Kagan, and Jackson. Justice Ginsburg said that she “count[s] [her]self as an originalist, too.” Justice Kagan declared during her Senate confirmation hearing that “we are all originalists.” Justice Jackson went even further, committing to the Senate that “[a]dherence to text is a constraint on my authority . . . You’re bound by the text and what it meant to those who drafted it.”
But if everyone agrees on originalism in principle, then why is originalism still so controversial? Why do originalists face such derision from the media and the academy?
The reason is actually quite simple. We may now all be originalists in theory. But something happens when you start to apply originalism in certain contexts—when originalism leads to results that just happen to be despised by those who lead the national discourse.
When that happens, originalists face a concerted campaign of condemnation. Originalists are disparaged and destroyed. We’re not merely wrong as an intellectual matter—we’re not just disagreeing in good faith about the proper meaning of legal terms—we’re fundamentally bad people who are too extreme for polite society.
We’re mean-spirited, racist, sexist, homophobic. We’re just trolling—or auditioning. We’re unethical—if not corrupt.
It’s the exact same pathos we see on college campuses: It’s not enough that I disagree with you—I also have to dislike you, and disparage and disrespect you as a human being. Instead of judging your reasoning, I pass judgment on the person behind it. I don’t presume good faith—I impute malicious intent.
And it’s obvious what’s going on here. There have been plenty of threats about packing the courts. But there’s no need to pack the courts, when you can just pressure the courts, and get the same result.
And make no mistake: This matters. This works. I would submit that the principal challenge that originalists face is not a matter of intellect, but a matter of intimidation and insult.
Because it is a basic fact of human nature that it is too often, for too many of us, easier to do what is popular than to do what is right.
* * *
The Chief Justice famously compared judges to umpires during his Senate confirmation hearing.
I agree with the analogy. But I draw a very different message from it. I see it as a cautionary tale.
I’m sure that there are many sports fans in the room—and that you’re all well aware of the phenomenon known as home field advantage.
Well, those who have studied home field advantage have concluded that it’s real—that the biggest cause of home field advantage is the referees—and it’s because the referees are responding to the booing of the crowd.
A number of studies show that umpires and referees across different sports will alter their calls, to avoid the booing of the crowd. It’s such a common phenomenon that there’s a name for it: It’s called “working the refs.”
And here’s the thing: There’s every reason to fear that the problem is even more extreme when it comes to judges.
After all, people usually don’t know the names of umpires and refs. So the booing is temporary. It goes away after a few moments. But the elites know full well how to boo and demean judges for the rest of their lives. And judges who have spent their entire lives collecting gold stars from cultural elites will adjust accordingly.
* * *
The pressure to conform isn’t just coming from outside the judiciary. It comes from within as well.
From day one, Chief Justice Roberts has expressed his strong view that he wants greater unanimity in Supreme Court decisions—even if it means narrower, and thus less originalist, rulings. He has vowed to discourage all of his colleagues from writing separately. As he put it bluntly, “every justice should be worried about the Court acting as a Court and functioning as a Court, and they should all be worried, when they’re writing separately, about the effect on the Court as an institution.”
Roberts specifically invoked the example of the Supreme Court under Chief Justice John Marshall, which was famous for its pursuit of unanimity. When Justice William Johnson felt compelled to write a dissent over two centuries ago, he acknowledged that it was “painful” to do so. And he said that he was “relieved” that at least it wasn’t a solo dissent—he was thankful that he was at least joined by one of his colleagues.
Justice Johnson’s fear of dissenting alone should be familiar to anyone who knows anything about human nature.
We all know about the fear of missing out. But just as powerful is the fear of sticking out.
In The Inner Ring, C. S. Lewis observed that “one of the most dominant elements” of the human experience is what he calls “the lure of the caucus”—and the “terror of being left outside.” He calls the desire to belong “one of the great permanent mainsprings of human action.” And he warns that “the passion for the Inner Ring is most skilful in making a man who is not yet a very bad man do very bad things.”
The fear of sticking out is not unique to the judiciary. Nor is it limited to judicial opinions.
A few years ago, I concluded that the intolerance at certain elite law schools was so bad that I would no longer hire law clerks from certain schools. I was convinced that, if enough judges joined the effort, the law schools would change their behavior in a heartbeat. But very few joined.
Since then, law students regularly ask me: Why haven’t more judges joined the boycott?
Well, you’d be surprised how many judges told me: Love what you’re doing. Please keep doing it. But sorry I can’t join you.
You’d be surprised how many judges told me: Well, if you can get other judges to join you, then I’ll join you, too.
Look, I get it. There’s safety in numbers. It’s scary to be alone, or in the extreme minority.
But Deuteronomy 20 reminds us that, when you go to war, don’t be afraid of an army greater in number than yours. Just worry about being on the right side—and the rest will take care of itself.
* * *
Let’s face it: Disruption is difficult. Because being different is difficult.
And that explains why so much of Senator Cruz’s new book focuses on Justice Thomas’s upbringing.
As I’ve explained, many judges are vulnerable to the lure of status, prestige, and popularity.
Justice Thomas is different because Clarence Thomas has always been different—from the very beginning. The Senator’s hopeful message in the book is that, if you’ve spent your early years getting used to being unpopular—and being okay with it—you may be less vulnerable to the seduction of popularity later in life.
Some of Justice Thomas’s solo dissents have now become the law of the land. Some haven’t yet, but perhaps someday will. And some will never.
My point is not to ask you to endorse any particular dissent by Justice Thomas—just as I am not asking you or agree or disagree with that lone juror in Massachusetts.
Rather, my point is simply this: I hope that each and every one of you will graduate from the University of Austin with passion, and with fortitude. Passion—to persuade your fellow man of the righteousness of your cause, whatever it may be. And fortitude—to stand alone when necessary, if that’s what you think principle and truth require.
After serving as President of the United States, John Quincy Adams returned to Congress, where he dedicated his energies to the cause of abolition and ending slavery.
A man named Abraham Lincoln would witness Adams’s passion while serving alongside him in Congress for one term. Lincoln would carry his torch—and eventually end slavery.
But that was long after Adams’ death. Adams himself never saw success. The majority of Congress was steadfastly opposed to his efforts.
A reporter asked Adams why he fought so hard for abolition, when it was so obviously a hopeless cause. Adams reportedly turned to him and said: “Duty is ours—results are God’s.”
Justice Thomas has similarly been asked how he takes so much heat, yet keeps on fighting. Here’s what Justice Thomas said in response:
Whether people are mad at you has nothing to do with whether you’re right. You can be in the middle of a hurricane. Or you can be on a calm day. North is still north. You can be in a thunderstorm. North is still north. People can yell at you. North is still north. It doesn’t change fundamental things. And in this business, right is still right. Even if you stand by yourself.
I can’t think of a better model—for the academy, or for the judiciary. I pray that the leaders of this University will keep teaching all of you what Justice Thomas has been trying to teach every American—that north is still north, and right is still right, even if you stand by yourself.
Thank you for listening.
Save the Constitution. Ditch the ABA.
With support from the Federalist Society, UATX is building the future of legal education.
UATX’s general counsel Adam Biggs explains what we intend to build, and why this is the perfect time to do so:
Public Events This Fall
All events are on campus in downtown Austin and free to attend.
September 22 · 5:30–7:00 PM: RSVP
How Think Tanks Think
Robert Doar, President, American Enterprise Institute.September 24 · 5:30–7:30 PM: RSVP
Impact in the Federal Government
Scott Kupor, Director of the Office of Personnel Management, and Joe Lonsdale, Co-Founder of UATX. Co-sponsored by The David Network.September 29 · 5:30–7:00 PM: RSVP
Are Recessions Inevitable?
Tyler Goodspeed, Chief Economist, ExxonMobil.October 13 · 5:30–7:00 PM: RSVP
The Myths of American Capitalism
Phil Gramm, former U.S. Senator and economist.November 3 · 5:30–7:00 PM: RSVP
Allies at War
Tim Bouverie, author and historian.November 10 · 5:30–7:00 PM: RSVP
Nazi-Communism: Why Marxist-Leninists and Nazi Fascists are Ideological Twins
Alex Kaiser, author and historian.More to be announced soon.
We charge you nothing, except everything you’ve got.
Rigorous education. $0 tuition. Merit-based admission.
Follow the University of Austin
X | Facebook | Instagram | LinkedIn | YouTube | Substack | Spotify | Apple












